
When I started collecting books in the mid-to-late 80’s, one of the first things I noticed were collectors exhibiting a fervent dedication to completeness. A true Kerouac enthusiast, for instance, sought not only On the Road, but also every Kerouac contribution made to little magazines, slick periodicals, and ephemeral broadsides: scoring a scarce copy of Yugen; searching for the men’s skin mag Escapade that featured Kerouac’s opine piece “The Last Word” (I think it appeared in 4 different issues; however, I can’t say for sure — except to say Kerouac was contracted to write 12 pieces but the magazine failed before they were completed); or maybe splurging on one of the 100 copies of A Pun For Al Gelpi that exist. This meticulous pursuit extended to other literary giants as well.
I got bit by the Bukowski bug early in my collecting adventure. I can tell you if there was one completist that may never have existed, it’s the Bukowski Completist. For a very brief moment, I contemplated making such a run. But I quickly realized the sheer impossibility of the task. (I could add the sheer madness as well). Buk’s work appeared in an overwhelming number of obscure publications, from his earliest appearances in print to the countless small press journals, underground mages / “littles”, to every iteration of John Martin’s fantastic Black Sparrow Press editions. Tracking them all down wasn’t just difficult—it was a never-ending pursuit, a costly rabbit hole with no bottom — certain to drive one to ruin. Both emotionally and financially.
I bring this up only because last Sunday at the Georgetown flea, I pulled a few of the Ringling Brothers magazines. I know there’s some circophiles still left, and the price for all three was right. When I got back to my Air BnB, I discovered one of them featured the Hemingway nonfiction piece, “The Circus.” It wasn’t very good, and as I finished it up, I wondered just where Hem was financially in 1952 that would have made him even want the gig – let alone take it. And I’m guessing forty years ago, such a find would have been a gem for the Hemingway completists. In 2025, however, the landscape of book collecting has shifted, prompting my question: Where have all the completists gone?